Something that I don't really see anyone bring up but seems to be at the root of a lot of online discourse/issues between transmasc and transfeminine cultures is that over the past several decades a large chunk of masculinity has been dragged into femininity or 'femaleness.' (or well plenty of people talk about this but I mean specifically with a focus on trans people.)
But trans men didn't really get the memo lol.
This works well for trans women to some extent because it means as long as they have feminine bone structure or can pass as reasonably female they get to be feminine but clearly a lot of non-conforming women, trans men and certain non-binary people end up having issues with this. Many people they look up to as icons of alternative masculinity end up coming out as trans women or transfemme, trans women accuse trans masc people of 'stealing their culture' or appropriating it or wanting to be trans women etc.
These kind of ridiculous arguments:
I feel like it's hard to 'rape' those guys when they're sending you private messages saying they Spoiler: want to suck your dick after you told them you weren't interested already and actually blocked them on another website because they weren't accepting that and you don't even have a dick and they know that because you posted about being non-binary and genetically female all the time and they follow all your posts.Why would trans men want to identify as 'deceitful gay male rapists of straight men'?
I'm aware there are cooked people everywhere, but "I identify as the transmisogynistic caricature invoked for the trans panic defense" is perhaps where we should be drawing some lines.
I dunno they didn't really try to communicate with me in any other way before getting to that point and didn't send me pictures of themselves or anything so there was no basis to form attraction based on either personality or appearence. I had nothing to work with.
I don't think femboys are a central example of this type since I don't think most trans men or non-binary people and certainly over a certain age have any interest in using the label femboy and femboy is more associated with a specific infantalised image as I said and also this which doesn't appeal to everyone (although I think a lot of feminine trans guys are bottoms and/or submissive sexually from what I noticed anecdotally):
But something similar often occurs anyway.What do you think the implication of femininity being conflated with submission means about femboy culture?Your a sub because you think femininity has to mean submission
I'm a sub because I know femininity looks better with domination
The femboy discourse specifically though gets really insane like this trans woman is considerably older I think actually but the kids are not OK:
You mean aging lol? I think the ultimate irony like some kind of cosmic irony is a while back people were making memes about Leonardo Dicaprio the way he looked when he was in Titanic and the Terminator films (wait wrong guy lmfao. That was Edward Furlong. I'm leaving this in because that's hilarious. They're all one person to me,) and comparing it to now and then discussing his constant switching to younger girlfriends that's become a meme too he can't date anyone over age 25 (supposedly.) That is funny. He became the chaser (of young people,) now. It's working for him though because he's straight and succesful. Well the media aren't happy at all because you're supposed to find older women more attractive or something.The femboys are developing Femboy Nationalism because the bodies of women are no longer theirs to control.oof. This is why I don't trust c*s male femboys, because the worst part is that she's right 💀 I've seen this happen way too many times. Traitors, every single one of em. I'll respect their new gender but god, it sucks to keep losing femboys either to this bullshit or twink death
I find older women attractive. In the film contact Jodie Foster was- oh wait I'm 33 too. Never mind.
Oh that's right I'm old now.
Leo is 49 so I'm not sure what age women he should be dating.
Eh tbf we watched that film when we studied it in school and I'm 33. So I guess the answer is 'older than 33' lol. These jokes could be better."DiCaprio's girlfriend is so young she probably studied the Romeo and Juliet film he starred in when she was at school," a second chimed in.
Does it count if the person is old but the photo is younger? I thought I'd seen most photos of young Geddy Lee at this point (and gifs) but just found this one I haven't seen before while browsing tumblr:
I wonder what their position is on time travel cloning.
It's difficult to socially age as an androgynous afab person unless you go on testosterone or are Kate Moennig and that's a horrifying existence (awkward sentence construction Kate Moennig escaped the horrifying existence I'm saying):
I didn't really need to link a video but OK.
Also the cultural bubble they're in is funny. Like Leisha talks 16:30 minutes in about going to get her nails done with someone and how everyone around her were like 'gross why did you get them done?' and she doesn't like them but she wants to keep them to show her that she kept them LOL. I clicked to a random part of the video so I don't know who she went with (edit: her niece,) and Kate's just like 'I don't think anyone noticed your fingers.' And she's like 'people will notice if they're looking.' You can't even see her hands in the video though lol. This kind of culture is not very fun if you're a very feminine person though.
I mean it's really down to bone structure and body language and your voice pitch if you want to not look/seem like a teenager forever.
Otherwise so much of adult womanhood is tied up with feminine expression and obviously secondary sex characteristics. Very little choice. I can't imagine this hysteria about age gap relationships and height gap relationships and so on is going to help this either. I bet lots more people are going to develop self image issues about this.
I have photos of myself from my mid 20s where I just look like a teen boy or something sometimes emo teen boy. I looked back. Another reason I can't have short hair though I like long hair so it's not that bad.
I mean it will happen eventually but it takes a long time. I remember finding someone online who was agender and felt they related to Cassandra the vampire child from Interview with the Vampire and I kind of got that and contemplated that myself.
Kind of anti-femboy in that sense lol.
And then I love how his response to 'femboys are developing nationalism' was just 'I'm a trans man' as though that's a defence against tribalistic tendencies what?:
I also think a lot of this circle hate 'fujoshi' for similar reasons. Essentially the bishonen aesthetic overlaps with aesthetics of Western angels and Greco Roman culture and they dislike this and also see it as a threat to transfemininity. I feel like they probably hate kpop too. Lesbian culture emphasises this kind of androgynous ideal too though like a large chunk of it. Slightly different from the specific femboy presentation that appeals to cis straight men sexually but still similar.I'm a trans man.that doesnt exempt you from misogyny or transmisogynyMy sister is a trans woman and I'd kill if someone misgendered her.You still follow a regressive and misogynistic cultureFemboys aren't a "regressive and misogynistic" culture, are you stupid?It is quite literally part of the reconstruction of patriarchal and pederastic culture of Roman masculinism.You know you're being transphobic towards me by not respecting my gender identity and how I present myself."You are reconstructing the Roman ideal of masculinism" is actually the opposite of not respecting your identity.
They're trying to recreate the gender war of cishet culture and trans men who end up in these debates online are just not really playing along propery and even bring up the fact they're trans as a defence against the idea that they could be oppressing them or misogynistic. Plus if you're afab most of the time at some point you will have experienced misogyny it's built into transphobia but pointing that kind of thing out is another thing a lot of this circle dislike. Sometimes less often cis gay men will do the same thing like use their homosexuality as a defence against why they can't be misogynistic especially if they're feminine. Which frustrates them.
But I think the whole thing is mostly dumb lol so.
Stumbled on this post I read a while ago again a couple of days ago which fits in:
Apparently just unironically using 'theyfab' now fucking 4chan lol...I was chilling with a theyfab friend telling them that I present masculine and feminine in and 70:30 ratio. Then they asked about how I feel about presenting androgynous.
One thing led to another and the conversation turned to male rock stars and visual k idols. When they dress androgynously its seen as subversive and scandalous even. Its distinctive.
When females do it they are just a tomboy. There needs to be outright masculinity for GNC status. I know rationally that this is because during the sexual revolution, on mass, women started embracing androgynous style and to sustain itself patriarchy needed to adapt. But its still a blackpill.
Whilst neither myself or my friend are identified with the woman label however we still both feel stifled by this reality.
Its honestly a blackpill that ill never be atsushi Sakurai
iwnbas
Oh that's that guy from this band they're talking about. Also didn't realise but he died last October apparently:
Something like this has happened 3 times that I'm aware of with visual kei or similar genre musicians from Japan twice while in concert which is kind of weird. I mean I've only listened to severel visual kei bands so yeah. There was one of the members of the band ADAMs who had a stroke on stage in Poland and died and then the lead singer of the band Kagerou I was reading about that band and it turned out he died in 2010 from a heart attack I think? At age 31. I feel like there are some other people I heard about and I'm forgetting about too. I mean he was a bit older but still not that old.After falling ill during a Buck-Tick concert, Sakurai died from a brainstem hemorrhage in a Yokohama hospital on October 19, 2023.
So I'm not the only one who's noticed. There are a bunch of Japanese musicians and actors who have died by suicide though where they're up front about it being suicide so I dunno. But this might be like the '27 club' thing where they did a paper and found people are just paying more attention to that but it's not actually more common. Also maybe related to this:Has anyone noticed how many artists in the VK scene die of brain aneurisms? Strange sicknesses? I always thought it was strange, and not the whole truth- maybe the other members were covering for suicides or something. Has anyone ever noticed this?
Anyway I thought at the time that Lady Gaga sort of pulled this off but people ultimately ended up thinking she was a trans woman so not really. And there's discourse about that too as well even more so with Aubrey Plaza when she once encouraged an interviewer to start a rumour that she has a dick.Karoshi (Japanese: 過労死, Hepburn: Karōshi), which can be translated into "overwork death", is a Japanese term relating to occupation-related sudden death.[1]
The most common medical causes of karoshi deaths are heart attacks and strokes due to stress and malnourishment or fasting. Mental stress from the workplace can also cause workers to commit suicide in a phenomenon known as karojisatsu (過労自殺).[1]
Trans women really hate it when cis women or when non-binary people and sometimes trans men but less often especially if they go on hrt - try to give off the impression online that they're amab (because a lot of identity and expression is built online now so it's easier to do this,) so they can be treated like men who are just presenting in an androgynous way. Cause obviously doing this relies on the assumption sometimes that they are trans women and that trans women are androgynous men.
On the contrary a lot of men are women lite now so we're just ahead of the curve. If right wing news sources going back over a hundred years are to be believed (and someone did make a long twitter thread compiling news articles going back over a hundred years lol,) then in about 50-300 years time the men will be so feminine (due to becoming more feminine for over a hundred years) that I will be considered an alpha male by those future standards. So it's all just a matter of time. When the transhumanists finally cure aging and enough time passes it will all make sense. Apparently Ben Shapiro and Tim Pool think they are alpha males which is good. I won't have to wait much longer.A trans woman I really thought I respected posted something about how she's tired of "theyfabs" because "they're just women lite and don't put in any effort to transition". It hurt to see since I'm AFAB and non-binary, and it made me feel like even other trans people see us as our AGABs. My best guess would be that she may have felt upset that people would willingly give up femininity, which is something I've heard from another trans girl mention when she saw some of her friends stop presenting femme.
Anyway I've invented a new form of nihilism built around the idea that I don't have a dick so it doesn't matter. And I don't really want to get surgery and I think that's pretty common not wanting surgery. And I don't even want a dick only for sex.
There's still the social dysphoria though so can't really win.
Yeah I've come across this before. Mostly trans women from 4chan. So what happens is they'll say they want to be afab non-binary (theyfab,) not cis women they weirdly specifically envy afab non-binary (and of course only a specific kind of feminine type,) then since they're women they get annoyed that non-binary people are you know non-binary and a lot of afab non-binary people are also men and enjoy being gendered as male realistically.I am just exhausted. A friend of mine, who is a binary trans woman, said something about wishing she was a "theyfab", and it was the first time I've ever heard the word.
After looking it up I'm just so disappointed and upset. I use any pronouns, and my gender identity is something I don't really think about at all. I am just a person. I guess you could say I'm "mostly fem presenting" but I just have long hair and wear clothes I look good in. Everyone sees me as a woman, which is frustrating and bothers me. I don't like being assigned characteristics based on the body I was born with. Obviously.
Yes there's a reason there are barely any amab non-binary people anyway that isn't our problem.My gut instinct is your binary friend isn?t as binary as she thinks she is and is struggling with some sunk cost fallacy shit.
I know that?s not relevant and I share in your frustration with that word.
Some people see this kind of thing as transgressive and that's why they like it, and for others it's just kind of who they are/normal they want it to be normalised they don't want it to be edgy and I do have a lot of sympathy with that especially when it comes to the subset of men who respond violently. It's quite difficult managing these two populations who have completly conflicting relationships to similar stuff.
F1nn gives off the impression of someone who's kind of trolling everyone like the recent clip I was talking about where he talks about the label femboy proabably dying out in a few years to be replaced with something else because everyone using it transistions and then calling his audience 'fellas for now' and things like that. And that annoys both cis and trans femboys who identify as men or really anyone who has that attachment. It's funny it bugs me (just describing my emotional reaction not making a value judgement,) and I'm bigender but gender is really weird for me. In one context I'm a guy and in another I'm a woman lol.
At other points he'll annoy trans woman because he plays into the 'trap' thing and jokes that men who are attracted to him are gay but also women I mean he makes this joke with his girlfriend sometimes. He's joked about that too. 'I get to decide when you're gay.' Very edgy. That's not in this video I cba searching:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rx1Et7B1bBA
I'm constantly reminded of just how fucking bored people are lol.
Also does things like this. He sent that to Andrew Tate and then got blocked:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ELmPNGQS6pc
I do think this kind of thing can be very entertaining. I mean I'm kind of sadistic in general (like lowkey sadism,) and I think this is an extension of that. You have to reign it in I guess or you should but I think at the point where they're being such huge assholes it's like 'you've given me permission.'
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ivzb1oJsnyw
"I benefited from honest to god homophobia they did not like me they were genuinely scared."
Also she said that one time she got roped into going to the toilet with a bunch of women in a nightclub and they all went into the same cubicle together to go to the toilet. That's the first time I've ever heard of anyone doing that and that is really not normal lol.
And this is the competition that trans women don't want to be involved in especially because of the violence.
And I started thinking about this again because aside from the makeup we wear really similar clothing and have similar build's and hair it's weird.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=45R8fqBGJmA
I also saw this video recently:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uIlNVYNsXOE
And I've spoken about Kurt Cobain before because this discourse has been going on for years. So I can't be bothered to touch on that aspect of this now. It's obvious though that he had a lot of issues and that suicide ran in his family for multiple generations actually. But you could see in the comments there were a lot of trans guys (or there were a bunch I'm too lazy to find now,) who talked about relating to him because of his relationship to hegemonic masculinity. Which didn't surprise me at all he's exactly the kind of guy that trans guys tend to model themselves on.
So you get this argument between trans masc and some non-binary people and especially [BEEP] trans women and transfemme people because straight trans women tend to be so feminine and so seperated that there's less overlap overall (think that was less true in the past, but certainly now,) but [BEEP] trans women are more androgynous on average so there are overlapping cultures etc.
The argument is a kind of territorial culture war over whether certain interests, ways of presenting, specific people are a non-conforming form of maleness and masculinity or womanhood. And obviously afab people in particular who are trans or trans-adj and are maybe dysphoric etc have a stronger connection to the male identity than amab trans and trans -adj people tend to so it becomes a huge issue.
And you get people lamenting about why all trans guys are feminine and androgynous or don't transistion medically and aren't very masculine but obviously a lot of the guys who are go stealth and also there's a general dislike of masculinity in certain cultures too which puts people off.
And in response to this sort of thing obviously Nyx (who is a trans woman,) created the gender accelerataionist blackpaper which talks about how everyone is being feminised and eventually the only gender left will be women. She didn't mean this in a 'this is good' sense though but in a 'this is what seems to be happening' sense. Which of course is an idea right wing men take seriously. The people who are most defensive against this idea are obviously the most masculine men because they are the group most identified with masculinity and maleness.
And you get writers like this one annoying chaser guy (prefers having sex with trans women especially in East Asia,) from Scotland who thinks there are essentially two genders but it's like masculine cis men and then everyone else. Sometimes he includes trans men if they're very masculine and straight (attracted to women.)
This argument is the core of a lot of issues though. Socially dysphoric afab people are not OK with being lumped exclusively or in some cases at all into womanhood and also won't commit to masculinity to the degree necessary and you have people going the other way who were always ambivalent and just like 'eh fine I guess I'm a woman sure.' Or they actively always saw themselves as women so it was ideal for them anyway.
And I love seeing the interractions also between trans women and non-binary people where they're completely confused by how people are doing things or they're desperately trying to make it fit into a dumb feminist ideological framework:
I don't think trans men ID as genderfluid, genderfluid seems like it's own thing that falls under the trans umbrella but it isn't a fixed position like trans man is.i know multiple who do.
take bi-gender man-women for example. if they were dfab, they've transitioned into manhood while maintaining a connection to womanhood. they often refer to themselves as bi-gender trans men, gender-fluid trans men, nby trans men, etc.Yeah so bigender again seems like an entirely different thing that we're lumping under the same umbrella as trans man when that's a specific identification with the patriarchal class of man, not man and woman.are bi-gender men not men?I suppose that'd depend on what their second gender is.yeaaahhh that makes no sense to me. they ID as men cuz they're menIf they ID as men then they ID with the patriarchal class.how do u think that interacts with bi-gender folk also IDing as a subordinate class? /genqI think the hegemonic class trumps the subordinate class in that case.ok i actually have a part 2 to this question cuz i just realized TME and TMA might be an important distinction. what if said bi-gender person was TMA? let?s say they?re transitioning MTF for simplicity?s sake. /genq i?m seriously wonderingI love how the end result is logic like 'I'm oppressing myself.' I mean technically that is a thing though people stop themselves from doing things they want to do all the time. But yeah that's actually why you can't really be a feminist and bigender. Well at least you can't be a [BEEP] theorist + feminist and bigender because there's too much invested in the differentiation of the groups man and woman.Well if they're adopting the social role and signifiers of womanhood then they will be read as woman within the class framework of patriarchy. I suppose it would depend on whether the bi-gender person is transitioning or not transitioning.
Then someone posted a meme image that had some image of a guy being brainwashed with 'trans girl indoctrination machine' on it and the text:
Either trolling or you've gone through some [BEEP] but actually some people are still attracted to men and going on estrogen generally makes more men attracted to you not less especially if you're reasonably feminine. This is a problem if you are attracted to women:'I understand I deserve more than being a boy and being a sex object online for men I am a girl and a lesbian and should start hrt'
Just slightly different/overlapping demographic of men.
Black pill for you.
I just found this video while looking up the other and I think it's very difficult like it's hard if you're a feminine cis women but at least there's some knowledge of feminine bisexual women and to a lesser extent femme lesbians but because there's almost a 1:1 association in people's minds with being amab and expressing this level of femininity with being exclusively attracted to men this would be quite difficult:
Lol she says "all the trans women I know are straight I didn't know any trans lesbians" I'm not surprised because her social circle was probably people with similar gender expression.
Just study a video game related degree or hang out with programmers. During my time at uni I met one trans woman who had started transistioning who I think was into women, then there was this trans woman who at the time wasn't out as a trans woman but had a crush on me which I didn't reciprocate. She once commented I love you on one of my facebook pics and then deleted the message minutes later but I read it and that was awkward. We worked on a group project once with that trans woman actually weirdly but otherwise I didn't talk to her at all but she added me on steam and a bunch of websites like I posted poetry on this one site and she followed me there she didn't present femininely at all back then and I only found out she transistioned because my friend told me about it (since I stopped using facebook in 2014.) Also met someone who later came out as non-binary at uni who I had a crush on.
I guess the thought process here was 'oh hey I'm kind of bi/attracted to women too because of the tomboys' but not the best thing to comment on that video. I guess she's dating a cis woman anyway though.I'm trans girl, I like men but I love girls kinda tomboys OMG
I could date a girl with a masculine energy, but I couldn't date another trans girl
I think that only happens if you were strongly into women before transistioning otherwise I've seen this pattern happen before also with non-binary amab people after they transistion if they date guys before. That's just anecdotes though. But I imagine in some cases estrogen increases sexual fluidity.I've heard transitioning MTF makes you more into guys... that might be why being a lesbian as MTF is a bit more of a rarity.
Oh lol I watched that show Genderquake years ago and didn't recognise her from that (don't really remember what anyone on that show looks like now really though.) The main thing I remember is there was a stealth trans guy who went on the show and didn't want anyone to know he was trans but of course someone on the show figured it out (I mean he passed but just by being on the show people were going to wonder,) and then this woman on the show became attracted to him and found out and was bothered about that I think? Not cool that people outed him but I do wonder why would you go on the show if you're trying to be stealth in the first place lol? That made no sense to me.
Waait. Is she the woman who was like making out with another woman on the show and in this video is saying 'that experience turned me into a lesbian' LOL how is that super straight. Oh my god. She said in her YouTube video that she was saying on the show she wanted a husband and a dog etc but now didn't want any of that besides maybe the dog. But even on the show she was making out with a woman lol. If that's her.
I have this vague memory of her kissing Howie in a hot tub which my brain has probably invented. But it seems there was a part where people were in a hot tub and obviously at some point they kiss.
Quoting from the documentary.
"Over the last few days Howie and Campbell have spent much of their time together. She has changed my perception like I wouldn't say I'm bisexual, wouldn't say I'm a lesbian. I'd say I'm straight. Considering I used to be male and hearing that a lesbian fancies me it's weird isn't it?"
"I do find her attractive, I think she's very pretty. Before I had my operation I'd never even want to experiment that way because I'd feel really masculine."
It's sounding very straight. Yeah I remember this now lol. I remember thinking yeah you're not straight lol.
Then they're playing truth or date and she uses her dare to get another woman whose name I forget to kiss Howie hahahahha 24 minutes in:
Maybe that's what I'm thinking of? But she was definitely talking about Howie in that other clip so something else must have happened. I'm not watching the whole thing again lol to find it plus that's the only episode that's up on YouTube anyway.
Some of these people on twitter are actually on drugs too and like tweeting while on drugs which isn't going to help. I mean they admit to that lol.
I don't do drugs because I'm naturally insane. Lol:
"I don't do drugs, I am drugs." Salvador Dali
LOL while googling that quote the top result was:
'NHS Drug addiction: getting help'
[BEEP] off lol. It's literally in the quote.
I did drink socially while at uni and don't now. For me it was more fun with other people around. And at the same time not fun potentially because when I used to drink I'd get bored and my tolerance for boredom decreased or I guess I became more vocal about that because I would say it's low anyway. So I'd just nag people to do stuff or go to some club I liked while I was at a house party. I can be like that sober with people I'm comfortable with sometimes. 'Let's go on an adventure in the middle of the night on News Years Eve to find vending machines.' This was actually something I proposed to my brother sans alcohol and he was like 'no there's going to be drunk people everywhere and why are you asking at twenty minutes to midnight?' I'm a very annoying person.
Also all of this also reminds me of this in the opposite direction:
It shouldn't be seen as a 'win' in the first place though. I think you can temper this or divert it to something else possibly (music stan culture vs sports teams vs literal nationalism vs gender vs sexuality vs religion, vs all the religious denominations of Christianity alone, vs websites - 4chan vs tumblr etc,) but I also think the total removal is a bit idealistic because you're working against how the Human mind works. Nobody's figured out what to do about that so I'm not going to lol.oh [BEEP] i just remembered Hard Candy. Elliott really ate that"Elliot hasn't explicitly said they're masc"
I understand this is a special win for the trans people using he/him pronouns but I CANNOT overemphasize how important Elliot's performance in Hard Candy was for me as a closeted she/her teenager. (I will not explain this.)
I liked the concept of Hard Candy though unsurprisingly and for obvious reasons given *gestures at post*